Ice Cream Menu

Scooping Happiness Every Single Day

We make all of our ice cream by hand, in small batches, AND we make everything that goes into our ice cream, including the brownies, peanut brittle, marshmallows, and the snickerdoodles for Ricanelas. We have delicious homemade toppings to jazz up your ice cream, including almond toffee, graham crackers, and spiced pecans, to name just a few of the most popular. Oh, and don’t forget about the decadent dark chocolate hot fudge and salted caramel sauces to top it all off.

Seasonal Flavors

Maple Walnut

Made with with Mead & Mead Maple Syrup, this sweet and nutty fall flavor is the perfect pairing for your favorite pie.

Peanut Butter Swirl

Peanut butter ice cream with a peanut butter ribbon and some crunchy chocolate pearls to create that classic combo!

Birthday Cake

Cake and ice cream are all in one cup with this delicious combination of vanilla ice cream, chocolate cake pieces and tons of rainbow sprinkles

Brandy Apple Dumpling

Sage Brown Butter ice cream with apple compote, a cinnamon crust and a hint of brandy. The Apple Dumpling Gang would be proud!

Pumpkin Cheesecake

Quintessential holiday classic dessert turned into a rich, creamy, perfectly spiced ice cream with graham crackers

Signature Flavors

Black Sesame

This toasty, nutty, and salty ice cream is made with a super special black sesame from Japan

Ricanelas

A staff and guest favorite, this cinnamon ice cream with snickerdoodle cookies is a perfect complement for all the other ice cream flavors

Salted Caramel

Hands down our most popular flavor, this ice cream is sweet, creamy, bitter, and salty, perfectly hitting every note

TCHO Chocolate

A rich, chocolate fudgy ice cream that tastes unlike any other because it's made with TCHO cocoa powder

Chocolate Coconut

Vegan coconut milk and TCHO cocoa powder makes this non-dairy ice cream super rich and creamy

Mint Chip

Made with Seely’s organic mint oil and our super thin chocolate shards that melt perfectly in your mouth

Honey Lavender

Steeped with organic dried lavender and paired with an outstanding Sonoma honey that is harvested just for us, this is unique, must-try flavor

Ritual Coffee Toffee

Fresh ground Ritual Coffee beans cold stepped for bold, exacting flavor is paired with housemade almond toffee for a sweet nutty crunch

Roasted Banana

Bananas are roasted with brown sugar to intensify their flavor [uniquely made with Double 8 Jersey Milk]

Vanilla

Nothing's boring about this vanilla, made with organic Madagascar vanilla beans for a sweet, creamy velvety toasted marshmallow flavor

Malted Vanilla

Inspired by the classic diner malted milkshake this flavor features housemade peanut brittle and delicate pieces of milk chocolate folded into vanilla ice cream

Cookies and Cream

We're not sure who loves this sweet cream ice cream with chopped chocolate sandwich cookies more, kids or adults, but there are cookies in every bite so we think everyone will be happy

Soft Serve Flavors

Available at the 18th Street Creamery Only (subject to slight variation)

  • Monday: Salted Caramel and Chocolate
  • Tuesday: Green Tea and Black Sesame
  • Wednesday: Roasted Banana and Cinnamon
  • Thursday: Coconut and Chocolate
  • Friday: Pumpkin and Vanilla
  • Saturday: Salted Caramel and Vanilla
  • Sunday: Vanilla and Chocolate