Talking Turkey

We sat down with Bi-Rite’s 19-year veteran Meat and Seafood Category Manager, Chili Montes, to chat heritage breeds, broad-breasted birds and how to pick the perfect turkey for you. Includes editor's notes for special Holiday 2020 considerations.

Come Thanksgiving, we’re often overwhelmed for choice when it comes to turkey options. Why are heritage turkeys one option we should consider?

There are a few main reasons to consider buying a heritage bird. First off, heritage birds have pure genetics and are pasture raised. The word “heritage” refers to ten specific breeds that were raised in America prior to the 1930s. These birds are anatomically very different from the more typical broad-breasted varieties and therefore both taste and cook differently. They have longer legs, a stronger bone structure, thicker bone density and can actually fly. These birds have a fuller flavor and, I’d say, if you’re intrigued by the diversity and genetics of heritage birds, it could be a great option for you. [Editor’s Holiday 2020 note: heritage turkeys are a great option if your holiday table will be seating fewer people this year. The smallest size is perfect for four to eight servings. We recommend planning on one pound of turkey per serving.]

Are there many ranchers raising heritage breed turkeys?

No, they’re actually extremely limited. This is due in large part to the industrialization of poultry in the 1930s. Large companies came on the scene and implemented efficiencies that, over time, created commodity poultry. That said, one producer in particular, Frank Reese of Good Shepherd Poultry Ranch, has had a dramatic impact on saving the species. Known as the godfather of heritage turkeys, Reese is a third-generation poultry farmer in Kansas who has preserved the pure breed lines of several heritage breeds that were either undesirable or soon to become extinct, including Standard Bronze, White Holland, Blacks, Narragansett, and Bourbon Red.


The “godfather of heritage turkeys” is a pretty impressive title. How has Frank Reese shaped the heritage turkey industry? 

It is an impressive title and extremely well-deserved. I traveled to Good Shepherd Poultry Ranch last year, along with Chris Timm, our Divisadero Market’s Butcher Department Head, to spend time with Frank and see his operation first-hand. A prominent figure in the Slow Food movement, he’s a one-man operation raising heritage turkeys the traditional way. So, you see, he really is the godfather of heritage turkeys. 

Tell me about the other turkeys Bi-Rite is offering this year. What’s special about each of them?

Every year we set out to source the best-tasting, ethically raised, broad-breasted birds available. This year we’re once again partnering with our friends at Pitman Family Farms in California’s Central Valley. They’re a third-generation, family owned and operated farm and have been raising their turkeys free-range and without antibiotics since 1954. An excellent local option, we’re proud to offer Mary’s certified organic birds which are always full of delicious, traditional flavor.

How do you guide guests towards finding the right bird for them? What questions should we ask ourselves? Also, any cooking tips for the big day?

Generally speaking, if you know you want a lot of white meat on the table, are after that traditional flavor, or are especially looking forward to using your leftovers in delicious new ways, a broad-breasted bird may be for you. If you’re not sure, I’d recommend you come in to the Markets and talk to me or one of our butchers. We’re always happy to chat and can help steer you in the right direction. For a traditional roast turkey recipe, check out our recipe and tips for how to maximize flavor. [Editor’s Holiday 2020 Note: we know visiting the Markets is a little more challenging right now, so “Team Turkey” is available via phone (415-321-8070 ext. 1), email, or via chat on our online store this year to help guide you through your Thanksgiving meal planning.] 


Photo credit: Jim Richardson

Related Content

The Bi-Rite Vinaigrette

Delicate and well balanced, this dressing complements just about any veggie or grain you choose - in fact, it is the back-bone of some of our most popular deli salads.

Kitchen Tricks: Get the most out of your loaf

Make your bread last longer.

Sumac-Roasted Chicken du Monde

Inspired by Mom Mogannam, this tangy, citrusy, Middle Eastern roasted chicken dish is simple and delicious.

Tomato, Cucumber, and Chickpea Salad

Celebrate summer produce with this seasonal salad.